DDD Meetup about software design heuristics
Yesterday my colleague Niels and I went to the DDDBelgium meetup with a workshop on software design heuristics by Mathias Verraes. Find out here what we learned from it.
The workshop was in real DDD-style without digital tools and we used pen and paper, so there was no distraction. We started by dividing ourselves into groups of 2. Mathias asked us a question to first discuss from gut feeling and then in more detail how a system can send a certain message to another system.
The exact question was as follows:
There is a system (A) that calculates a prize up to 4 decimal places, and a system (B) that wants to receive that prize. How much information does the price contain that you send to system B, 4 or 2 digits. Several people in the audience had chosen 2 digits on gut instinct, and another part had chosen 4 digits.
After we had made our gut feeling known, we had to further discuss with our duos why we had made that choice. After that we distilled it into more generic patterns that can also be applied to other problems.
This allows you to see in a more analytical way why there are different opinions to solve a problem.
The arguments for the two possible options soon surfaced:
Pro 2 digits
- Hiding information
- Compliance with international standards
- Message size
- Do not duplicate ownership of the information (and business rules such as rounding)
Pro 4 digits
- Enclose all possible information
- Follow an existing contract/convention
Of course there was also a duo who went one step further and suggested to send the two versions at the same time, a heuristic came out as well: Are you sure that the proposed binary choices really are the only options?
This technique allows us to argue more clearly why your gut feeling goes for a certain solution and how to deal with it. This allows you to see in a more analytical way why there are different opinions to solve a problem.
Mathias did notice that this way of looking at a problem can take a lot of time. However, recognizing these heuristic patterns can help to look at a problem from multiple angles and come to a more complete solution.
Anyway, it was an interesting workshop, thanks to spilberg for hosting the meetup.